Luffy got the small scar beneath his left eye by stabbing himself with a knife when he was a child. In One Piece manga Chapter 1, he does it to prove to Shanks and his crew that he is brave enough to become a pirate. The mark is not a battle wound, and Shanks did not give it to him.
The scene is one of Eiichiro Oda's earliest character introductions. It also explains why readers who started with the television anime might remember the origin differently: the original TV opening rearranges the story, while later adaptations revisit Luffy's childhood.
Where does Luffy get the scar in the manga?
The answer appears right at the beginning of Chapter 1, Romance Dawn, collected in Volume 1. Young Luffy admires the Red Hair Pirates and desperately wants Shanks to take him to sea. Shanks treats him like a child and refuses. Luffy responds with a spectacularly bad demonstration of courage: he takes a knife and cuts the skin below his left eye.
The scene establishes two things at once. Luffy is willing to endure pain to chase his dream, but he is also impulsive and misunderstands what courage means. The adults are alarmed, not impressed by a sensible plan. The scar stays with him as a small, permanent reminder of that childhood stubbornness.
Did Shanks cause the scar?
No. Shanks is the person Luffy is trying to impress, not the person who wounds him. That distinction matters because Shanks does leave another lasting mark on Luffy's life: he saves the boy from a Sea King and loses an arm in the process. Those events are connected through the same childhood flashback, but they are separate injuries suffered by different people.
The scar also predates Luffy's mature pirate career. It is not a souvenir from fighting a Marine, a rival captain or one of the powerful enemies he meets on the Grand Line. In fact, it is part of his character design before the main voyage begins.
Why might anime viewers miss this scene?
The original One Piece television series introduces Luffy's voyage differently from the manga. Episode 1 opens with his encounter with Alvida and Koby, rather than reproducing the entire opening chapter's childhood sequence. Episode 4, Luffy's Past! The Red-Haired Shanks Appears!, covers the formative Shanks flashback, but the self-inflicted scar moment is not presented in the same way as the manga's opening.
This is why an anime-only viewer can recognize the distinctive stitch-like mark for hundreds of episodes without remembering an explicit explanation. It is not a hidden mystery whose answer arrives during the final saga. The manga already supplies the cause in its first chapter.
Some later anime material and adaptations revisit the childhood period. The safest reference for the precise origin is still Oda's Chapter 1, rather than assuming every version includes every beat of the flashback. Adaptation omissions do not change the manga's explanation.
Is the scar connected to Luffy's Devil Fruit?
No. Luffy's eye scar is a normal childhood wound, not a side effect of eating a Devil Fruit or using Haki. The fruit he eats during his time around Shanks gives his body rubber-like properties, but the scar's origin is the knife incident. The later revelations about the fruit's true identity do not retroactively turn the mark into a supernatural symbol.
For a separate explanation of the power he gains, see AnimeSparks' Devil Fruit guide; the Gear 5 and Nika breakdown covers much later story revelations. Neither is necessary to understand how he got the mark.
What about the large X-shaped scar on Luffy's chest?
That is a different scar with a different origin, and confusing the two leads to misleading answers. The small cut under his left eye comes from his own childhood stunt. The prominent X-shaped scar across his chest is associated with the devastating injury he suffers from Admiral Akainu during the Marineford war, while Jinbe is trying to carry him to safety.
The distinction also separates early-series material from major spoilers. The eye scar is explained immediately in the manga. The chest scar belongs to a much later turning point involving Ace, Marineford and the two-year separation. Someone asking only about the mark below Luffy's eye does not need to learn the details of that later tragedy.
Why does the tiny scar matter to Luffy's character?
It is a compact introduction to Luffy's strengths and weaknesses. He has enormous resolve, but his first attempt to prove it is reckless. Shanks becomes a model for a more meaningful kind of bravery: protecting people and accepting sacrifice rather than merely showing that pain does not frighten you.
That reading is an interpretation of the scene, not a secret canon power attached to the scar. Luffy's choices across the story repeatedly test the difference between stubbornness and responsibility. The mark beneath his eye makes his earliest mistake visible even after he grows into a capable captain.
Readers interested in how Luffy's later abilities evolve can also consult AnimeSparks' Haki guide. Those systems explain his combat growth, whereas the eye scar tells a simpler story about the boy he was before the adventure.
The answer in one sentence
Luffy cut himself beneath the left eye with a knife as a child to impress Shanks, as shown in One Piece Chapter 1; it is neither a scar from Shanks nor the later X-shaped wound on his chest.







